> POVPlanet lacked in concept, but in artistic and technical, I
> think it's quite good.

I made a mistake when voting : for off-topic images I rated Artistic and
technical Merit as honestly as I could, but I was wrong, I think, now that
an off-topic image should be rated (1, 1, 1) : think of an image by Gilles
Tran, "in vitro" for instance, which IMHO is a great image :
http://www.oyonale.com/ldc/francais/invitro.htm, if Gilles had entered a
round whose topic is "railroads" I could have rated him (19, 19, 1) and he
can reach a place in the top-ten which would not have been fair to other
competitors.

Just my opinion

Philippe Gibone

Post a reply to this message